Skip to content
New sellers added regularly!
New sellers added regularly!

Under $25

Looking for meaningful gifts that don’t break the bank? Explore unique and affordable finds from Finger Lakes sellers, all $25 and under. From handmade treats and self-care essentials to charming accessories and thoughtful tokens, this collection proves that small gifts can still leave a big impression.

  • Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Finger Lakes Refrigerator Magnets

    Victor Wood Forge

    Finger Lakes Refrigerator Magnets - Handcrafted Wood Magnets These Finger Lakes Refrigerator Magnets are a must-have for anyone who loves the beaut...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Vintage Teacup Candle - handmade candles by Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Vintage Teacup Candle - handmade candles by Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $18.00 - $19.00
    $18.00 - $19.00
    Current price $18.00

    Vintage Teacup Candle

    Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes

    No Two Teacups Are Alike Each teacup is unique, and your order will arrive as a surprise selection. Every teacup is antique or thrifted from throug...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $18.00 - $19.00
    $18.00 - $19.00
    Current price $18.00
  • Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00

    Topographic Finger Lakes Coasters

    Victor Wood Forge

    Topographic Finger Lakes Coasters Bring the beauty of New York's Finger Lakes into your home with these handcrafted laser-engraved topographic coas...

    View full details
    Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00
  • Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Finger Lakes Christmas Ornaments

    Victor Wood Forge

    🎄 FREE SHIPPING on all Christmas Ornaments! Finger Lakes Christmas Ornaments - Laser Engraved NY Lake Ornaments Celebrate the beauty of New York's...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Cornered Quart.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00

    Quart Maple Syrup Plastic Jug

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00
  • Laser Engraved Stemless Wine - handmade beer glasses by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Laser Engraved Stemless Wine - handmade beer glasses by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Laser Engraved Stemless Wine

    Etched in the Finger Lakes

    Laser engraved stemless wine glass, dishwasher safe

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $0.00
    $0.00 - $0.00
    Current price $0.00

    Digital Download Test 2

    Eltimar Design

    Print Purchase Agreement and Terms of Sale1. Ownership of Intellectual PropertyMary D. Elliott, Eltimar Design, retains full, exclusive, and uncond...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $0.00
    $0.00 - $0.00
    Current price $0.00
  • Original price $10.00 - Original price $100.00
    Original price
    $10.00 - $100.00
    $10.00 - $100.00
    Current price $10.00

    Holiday Gift Card

    Shop Finger Lakes

    Not sure what to buy? Let them choose something they’ll love with a Shop Finger Lakes Holiday Gift Card. Perfect for anyone who appreciates handcra...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $100.00
    Original price
    $10.00 - $100.00
    $10.00 - $100.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Kettle-fresh, Homemade Fudge Cups - 6 oz

    Specc’s Chocolates and Gifts

    Small batches Made in Watkins Glen, NYRich, Smooth, Not too SweetShips fresh100% satisfaction guaranteed Gift your friends and loved ones (or maybe...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    Fudge Box: Contemporary Flair

    Specc’s Chocolates and Gifts

    Ideal for those who enjoy different! Four fudge cups ... at least 12 oz ... crafted to intrigue tastebuds. The perfect gift for someone you love - ...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    Fudge Box: Classic

    Specc’s Chocolates and Gifts

    A traditionalist's favorite: four fudge cups ... at least 12 oz of smooth, creamy goodness that brings memories to life. The perfect gift for someo...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Homemade Chocolates with Soft Centers

    Specc’s Chocolates and Gifts

    Hand-made in small batches, Specc's Chocolates are made one piece at a time, with high quality, fresh ingredients. These bite-sized candies explode...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Laser Engraved Slate Coasters - handmade coasters by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Laser Engraved Slate Coasters - handmade coasters by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.25
    $6.25 - $6.25
    Current price $6.25

    Laser Engraved Slate Coasters

    Etched in the Finger Lakes

    Laser Engraved Slate Coaster.

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.25
    $6.25 - $6.25
    Current price $6.25
  • QQWJ5058.JPG
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    Current price $6.00

    NY Raw Wildflower Honey (Choose size)

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    Current price $6.00
  • Limited Edition America 250 Pint Glass - handmade beer glasses by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Limited Edition America 250 Pint Glass

    Etched in the Finger Lakes

    Celebrate America's 250th with your own pint glass!!

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Maple LEaf Favor Transparent.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $3.25
    $3.25 - $4.00
    Current price $3.25

    Glass Maple Syrup Party Favor 50 ml (Choose Design)

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $3.25
    $3.25 - $4.00
    Current price $3.25
  • Laser Engraved Pint Glass - handmade beer glasses by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Laser Engraved Pint Glass - handmade beer glasses by Etched in the Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    Current price $10.00

    Laser Engraved Pint Glass

    Etched in the Finger Lakes

    Laser engraved pint glass

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    Finger Lakes Earrings/necklaces

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    Show your love for the Finger Lakes with these unique FLX Heart Earrings and necklaces! Each earring and necklace features a silver-tone round dis...

    View full details
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
  • Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    QKA Stainless Steel Pendant Necklace: Engraved Branch, Adjustable Cord, Finger Lakes Inspired

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    Carry a little piece of the Finger Lakes wherever you go. Our QKA Pendant Necklace features a beautifully engraved stainless steel pendant with a s...

    View full details
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
  • Sparkly Unique chain necklace - handmade necklaces by WM Unique Designs | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Sparkly Unique chain necklace - handmade necklaces by WM Unique Designs | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Sparkly Unique chain necklace

    WM Unique Designs

    Beautiful chain necklace with magnetic tube clasp for easy on and off. Choose from a variety of unique styles. Each piece is one of a kind.

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Wire wrapped gemstone donut on 18" black satin adjustable cord. - handmade necklaces by WM Unique Designs | Shop Finger
    Wire wrapped gemstone donut on 18" black satin adjustable cord. - handmade necklaces by WM Unique Designs | Shop Finger
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Wire wrapped gemstone donut on 18" black satin adjustable cord.

    WM Unique Designs

    Beautiful wire wrapped gemstone pendant on a black satin cord with a silver extender chain and lobster clasp making it easily adjustable. Choose yo...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Original price $12.75 - Original price $12.75
    Original price
    $12.75
    $12.75 - $12.75
    Current price $12.75

    Roasted Nuts - Combo

    Specc’s Chocolates and Gifts

    Roasted and glazed, these nuts are perfect for snacking, gifting or just to have on hand for when your neighbors stop by. Perfectly coated with cin...

    View full details
    Original price $12.75 - Original price $12.75
    Original price
    $12.75
    $12.75 - $12.75
    Current price $12.75
  • 4oz soap bar, colored brown, tan and white. Scented with dirt fragrance oils.
    4oz soap bar, colored brown, tan and white. Scented with dirt fragrance oils.
    Sold out
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    Dirt Bath & Body Soap

    Judds suds

    This bar is scented to smell exactly like fresh dirt. Perfect to use as before hunting. Pamper yourself every day with our invigorating Dirt Bath &...

    View full details
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
    Sold out
  • Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
    Original price
    $6.00
    $6.00 - $6.00
    Current price $6.00

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla Lotion Bar | Handmade Berry Body Butter Bar | Long-Lasting Natural Moisture

    Judds suds

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla Lotion Bar Indulge in a sweet and creamy classic with our Black Raspberry Vanilla Lotion Bar. This ultra-nourishing s...

    View full details
    Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
    Original price
    $6.00
    $6.00 - $6.00
    Current price $6.00
  • Jar of oatmeal milk and honey beard butter with a black lid on a white background
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Oatmeal Milk & Honey- Beard Butter

    Judds suds

    Oatmeal Milk & Honey Beard Butter – Warm • Comforting • Ultra-Conditioning Pamper your beard with the soothing comfort of Oatmeal Milk & Ho...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Jar of Cedarwood, Frankincense & Myrrh Beard Butter with a black lid on a white background
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Cedarwood Frankincense & Myrrh Beard Butter

    Judds suds

    Cedarwood Frankincense & Myrrh Beard Butter – Woodsy • Warm • Regal Indulge your beard in rich, woodsy luxury with our Cedarwood Frankincense &...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • 1.4oz glass roller bottle. Filled with frankincense essential oil and olive oil.
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00

    Frankincense Essential Oil Roller | 100% Pure Aromatherapy | Stress Relief, Grounding & Skin Support |

    Judds suds

      Experience the calming, grounding benefits of Frankincense with this convenient essential oil roller, crafted for on-the-go aromatherapy and dail...

    View full details
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00
  • 1.4oz  glass roller bottle, filled with grapefruit essential oil and olive oil.
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00

    Grapefruit Essential Oil, Roller ball

    Judds suds

    May suppress appetite, may promote weightloss, may help balance mood, may help reduce stress and lower blood pressure.   These statements are for i...

    View full details
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00
  • Two round shampoo bars wrapped in clear plastic, placed on a wooden surface.
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    CLARY SAGE & ROSEMARY ESSENTIAL OIL - Syndet Shampoo Bar

    Judds suds

    Clary Sage & Rosemary | Syndet Shampoo Bar | With Castor Oil | Herbal, Fresh & Clarifying | 3oz Give your hair a refreshing, gentle cleanse...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Original price $5.00 - Original price $5.00
    Original price
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Neem Oil Dog Wash

    Judds suds

    Keep your furry friend clean and free from pests with our Neem Oil Dog Wash. Made with natural neem oil, this dog wash helps repel fleas, ticks, an...

    View full details
    Original price $5.00 - Original price $5.00
    Original price
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Soothe and soften your nails with Luxury Lavender Cuticle Oil — a calming, hydrating blend that nourishes cuticles, strengthens nails, and leaves a gentle floral scent.
    Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
    Original price
    $6.00
    $6.00 - $6.00
    Current price $6.00

    Luxury Lavender Cuticle Oil – Moisturizing Nail & Cuticle Oil for Dry Cuticles

    Judds suds

    Luxury Lavender Cuticle Oil Unwind and restore with our Luxury Lavender Cuticle Oil, a soothing blend designed to hydrate, soften, and protect your...

    View full details
    Original price $6.00 - Original price $6.00
    Original price
    $6.00
    $6.00 - $6.00
    Current price $6.00
  • Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price
    $4.00
    $4.00 - $4.00
    Current price $4.00

    Rainbow Sherbet Bath Bomb – Kids Bath Bomb with Glow-in-the-Dark Surprise Toy Inside

    Judds suds

    Rainbow Sherbet | Bath Bombs Scent Notes: Orange • Pineapple • Raspberry • Vanilla Turn bath time into a sweet, colorful escape with our Rainbow Sh...

    View full details
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price
    $4.00
    $4.00 - $4.00
    Current price $4.00
  • Bottle of Blueberry Cheesecake body mist on a white background
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00

    Blueberry Cheesecake Body Spray – Sweet & Fruity Dessert-Inspired Fragrance

    Judds suds

    Blueberry Cheesecake Body Spray Indulge in a sweet, dessert-inspired fragrance with our Blueberry Cheesecake Body Spray. This delicious blend opens...

    View full details
    Original price $8.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00
  • Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price
    $4.00
    $4.00 - $4.00
    Current price $4.00

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla Bath Bomb – Kids Bath Bomb with Glow-in-the-Dark Surprise Toy

    Judds suds

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla Bath Bomb with Glow in the Dark Toy Inside – Fruity Kids Bath Bomb Surprise | Handmade Fizzy Bath Bomb Gift Make bath...

    View full details
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price
    $4.00
    $4.00 - $4.00
    Current price $4.00
  • Natural deodorant stick with a gray cap and white label on a white background
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Cedarwood & Frankincense Natural Deodorant – Aluminum-Free & Baking Soda-Free

    Judds suds

    Cedarwood & Frankincense Natural Deodorant Ground your daily routine with our Cedarwood & Frankincense Natural Deodorant. This warm, earthy...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • 3oz conditioner bar, scented with raspberry lemonade fragrance oil
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Raspberry Lemonade Conditioner Bar – Solid Hair Conditioner for Soft, Smooth & Manageable Hair

    Judds suds

    Raspberry Lemonade | Lightweight Conditioner | 3oz Scent Notes: Raspberries • Lavender • White Musk Refresh your hair with the bright, uplifting bl...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00