Skip to content
New sellers added regularly!
New sellers added regularly!

Under $25

Looking for meaningful gifts that don’t break the bank? Explore unique and affordable finds from Finger Lakes sellers, all $25 and under. From handmade treats and self-care essentials to charming accessories and thoughtful tokens, this collection proves that small gifts can still leave a big impression.

  • Sesame Seed Bagel - handmade bagels by The Quarters Kitchen | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Sesame Seed Bagel - handmade bagels by The Quarters Kitchen | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00 - $24.00
    $12.00 - $24.00
    Current price $12.00

    Sesame Seed Bagel

    The Quarters Kitchen

    The Sesame Seed Bagel is covered in White Sesame Seeds. Vegan friendly with no egg or dairy.

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00 - $24.00
    $12.00 - $24.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Custom Length Leather or Cotton Cord Necklace, 2mm Thick Genuine Leather, Genuine Woven Cotton, Made to Order Braided Bolo Necklace
    Custom Length Leather or Cotton Cord Necklace, 2mm Thick Genuine Leather, Genuine Woven Cotton, Made to Order Braided Bolo Necklace
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price
    $10.00 - $15.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    Current price $10.00

    Custom Length Leather or Cotton Cord Necklace, 2mm - 3mm Thick

    Gorges Wire Design

    See below for custom necklace cord info:- Your choice of leather or cotton color- Metal Type- Necklace Length* (MAX 30") Leather Options- Green Gen...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price
    $10.00 - $15.00
    $10.00 - $15.00
    Current price $10.00
  • *Clearance* Deep Green Leaf Dangles in Gold Brass - handmade earrings by Gorges Wire Design | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00

    *Clearance* Deep Green Leaf Dangles in Gold Brass

    Gorges Wire Design

    Care Instructions for All JewelryJewelry will tarnish over time, unfortunately any metal (enameled or treated for tarnish prevention) will oxidize ...

    View full details
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00
  • Original price $22.00 - Original price $22.00
    Original price
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $22.00
    Current price $22.00

    Hiking Boot Map Pins - Set of 12

    Victor Wood Forge

    Hiking Boot Map Pins (Set of 12) Transform your wall into a captivating chronicle of your explorations! Introducing our Cherry Hiking Boot Map Pins...

    View full details
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $22.00
    Original price
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $22.00
    Current price $22.00
  • Patchouli Citrus Soap - handmade bar soap by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Patchouli Citrus Soap

    Bounty & Blessings

    This soap is a sudsy, wake-me up kind of soap. Great for that morning shower.  Beautiful shea and coconut oil blend.Each bar is approximately 2.75"...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Finger Lakes depth chart ornament showing all 11 lake depths, handcrafted cherry and maple wood
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    Finger Lakes Depth Chart Ornament | NY Christmas Gift | Handcrafted Wood

    Victor Wood Forge

    🎄 FREE SHIPPING on all Christmas Ornaments! Finger Lakes Depth Chart Christmas Ornament Discover the hidden depths of New York's Finger Lakes with...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    New York State Finger Lakes Ornament | Christmas Gift | Handcrafted Wood

    Victor Wood Forge

    🎄 FREE SHIPPING on all Christmas Ornaments! New York State Finger Lakes Christmas Ornament Celebrate New York's most beautiful region with this st...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Neem & Rosemary Face & Body Bar - handmade bar soap by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Neem & Rosemary Face & Body Bar

    Bounty & Blessings

    Great nourishing and astringent oil blend. Neem oil contains anti-fungal and anti-bacterial compounds thought to be useful in the care of acne. Alw...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Goat Milk, Unscented - handmade bar soap by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Goat Milk, Unscented

    Bounty & Blessings

    Lovely and nourishing with Goat's Milk and Shea Butter. NO Fragrance or Essential oils, NO Dyes, NO Exfoliants. Each bar is approximately 2.75" x 2...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    Finger Lakes Heart Shaped Lake Names Ornament

    Victor Wood Forge

    🎄 FREE SHIPPING on all Christmas Ornaments! Celebrate your love for the Finger Lakes with this beautifully handcrafted heart-shaped ornament featu...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Natural Deodorant, Citrus Forest - handmade deodorants by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Natural Deodorant, Citrus Forest

    Bounty & Blessings

    Formulated with natural ingredients therefore, naturally safe and effective. Light scent. 3oz.nt.wt NO Aluminum  NO Paraben  NO Fragrance

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Lavender Sprig Soap - handmade bar soap by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Lavender Sprig Soap

    Bounty & Blessings

    Delightful garden soap with a lingering scent. Rich Shea Butter and nourishing oil blend creates this gentle nourishing soap.. Lavender Floral Embe...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Natural Deodorant, Lavender - handmade deodorants by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Natural Deodorant, Lavender

    Bounty & Blessings

    Formulated with natural ingredients therefore, naturally safe and effective. Light scent. 3 oz.nt.wt. NO Aluminum  NO Paraben  NO Fragrance NO Colo...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Tallow Mallow Creme - handmade face moisturizers by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00

    Tallow Mallow Creme

    Bounty & Blessings

    Fluff for your face! Whipped tallow enriched with skin-loving ingredients.. Crafted with locally-sourced tallow. Thank you Bedient Farms for the gr...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $8.00
    $8.00 - $8.00
    Current price $8.00
    Sold out
  • Blue bottle of 'Penny's' rosemary conditioner on a white background
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Clary Sage & Rosemary Essential Oil Liquid Conditioner – Herbal Detangling Hair Conditioner

    Judds suds

    Clary Sage & Rosemary | Essential Oil Liquid Conditioner | 8.90oz | Herbal, Lightweight & Nourishing Refresh and revive your hair with our ...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • 3oz shampoo bar. Contains detergents to gently clean and moisturize your hair.
    Sold out
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla - Syndet Bar (Solid Shampoo)

    Judds suds

    Black Raspberry & Vanilla | Syndet Shampoo Bar | 3oz | Juicy Berry, Vanilla Cream & Soft Musk Indulge your senses with our Black Raspberry ...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
    Sold out
  • Boy's romper - handmade baby & children's one-pieces by All Things Heirloom | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Boy's romper - handmade baby & children's one-pieces by All Things Heirloom | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Sale Sale
    Original price $30.00
    Original price $30.00 - Original price $30.00
    Original price $30.00
    Current price $23.00
    $23.00 - $23.00
    Current price $23.00

    Boy's romper

    All Things Heirloom

    Baby boy's one-piece romper-100 % cotton, whale theme, navy blue and light blue, white cording on front, size 12-18 mos. Whale buttons on front and...

    View full details
    Original price $30.00
    Original price $30.00 - Original price $30.00
    Original price $30.00
    Current price $23.00
    $23.00 - $23.00
    Current price $23.00
    Sale Sale
  • Cornered Maple Leaf.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Maple Syrup 250 ml Glass Maple Leaf

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Cornered Pint Jug.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Pint Maple Syrup Plastic Jug

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Cornered Maple Sugar Shaker.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    Current price $6.00

    Maple Sugar Shaker (Choose size)

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    $6.00 - $10.00
    Current price $6.00
  • Cornered half pint jug.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    Half Pint Maple Syrup Plastic Jug

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
  • Teddy bear onesie baby gift boy girl soft knit snaps by All Things Heirloom
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    Teddy bear onesie baby gift boy girl soft knit snaps

    All Things Heirloom

    New Teddy bear onesie, baby gift boy or girl, soft knit with snap closures, size 0-3 mos. -Always needed for the new baby.

    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Little girl's summer hat-pinks with visor type front by All Things Heirloom
    Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00

    Little girl's summer hat-pinks with visor type front

    All Things Heirloom

    Pinks abound on this little girl's summer hat with solid color visor and swirling colors.Fully lined with pink cotton

    Original price $9.00 - Original price $9.00
    Original price
    $9.00
    $9.00 - $9.00
    Current price $9.00
  • Baby boy or girl onesie shower gift soft knit size 0-3 mos Panda by All Things Heirloom
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    Baby boy or girl onesie shower gift soft knit size 0-3 mos Panda

    All Things Heirloom

    Pandas, New Onesie, boy or girl, baby gift, soft knit snap closures -Always needed for the new baby.

    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Baby Boy Whale Jumper, 100% Cotton, Whale Buttons (3-6 mos) - handmade baby & children's one-pieces by All Things Heirloom
    Baby Boy Whale Jumper, 100% Cotton, Whale Buttons (3-6 mos) - handmade baby & children's one-pieces by All Things Heirloom
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00

    Baby Boy Whale Jumper, 100% Cotton, Whale Buttons (3-6 mos)

    All Things Heirloom

    Baby Boy jumper with snap enclosure and whale buttons to match. 100% cotton. Could he be a sailor, whale watcher or beach goer? Size 3-6 mos. Need ...

    View full details
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00
  • Men's flat cap for spring/summer, fully lined, small-red and greens plaid head circumference-22 inches by All Things
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Men's flat cap for spring/summer, fully lined, small-red and greens plaid head circumference-22 inches

    All Things Heirloom

    Men's flat cap for spring/summer use. Fully lined-plaid-reds and greens-sporty and made from woven cotton.

    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00

    Confetti Patchwork Cotton Baby Dress, Lime & Pastel (6-12 mos)

    All Things Heirloom

    Summery dress for a tiny girl -Multiple pastel colors with lime green. Refreshing as the new season. 100 percent cotton 6-12 most.

    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00
  • Custom Pet Portraits - handmade item by Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99

    Custom Pet Portraits

    Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes

    Send your favorite pet photo and receive a minimal, hand-drawn style illustration, beautifully framed and matted. A timeless keepsake of your furry...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99
  • Set of 5 Canandaigua, NY Note Cards - handmade item by Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99

    Set of 5 Canandaigua, NY Note Cards

    Vintage + Wick l Finger Lakes

    Created from my own lake photography, these blank note cards are simple, timeless, and inspired by the beauty of Canandaigua Lake. Perfect for than...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99
  • Chamleon - handmade figurines by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00

    Chameleon Sun Catcher

    Buck's Unique Creations

    This whimsical little guy is tough to find because he's a chameleon hiding on a pine cone. Seriously, he is a cute little guy. Wire, beads, leaves ...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00
  • Lobster - handmade sculptures & statues by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00

    Lobster

    Buck's Unique Creations

    This red beaded lobster is a nice addition to your desk, on a wall, hanging in a window or around fish tank! Hand crafted using wire and beads. Thi...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00
  • Soap Royale - handmade item by Bounty & Blessings | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    Soap Royale

    Bounty & Blessings

    A touch of royalty, a dash of gold. Fragrant...amazing. Go ahead, you deserve it!

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
  • Flower Basket - handmade artificial flowering plants by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Flower Basket - handmade artificial flowering plants by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Flower Basket

    Buck's Unique Creations

    Who wouldn't want a basket of flowers that never needs water and throws rainbows across the room. This cute basket looks so good hanging in a windo...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Almost Spring - handmade item by Penniboo | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Almost Spring - handmade item by Penniboo | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Almost Spring

    Penniboo

    Almost Spring is a small watercolor painting completed on 100% hot press watercolor paper. This painting measures 3 1/2” x 5” work a small border. ...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Island View - handmade item by Penniboo | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Island View

    Penniboo

    This small seascape watercolor painting measures 4 1/2 “ x 3” with a small border. This painting is is sold unmatted & unframed and is painted...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Snake Pendant - handmade figurines by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Snake Pendant - handmade figurines by Buck's Unique Creations | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Snake Pendant

    Buck's Unique Creations

    This hand wired snake has a jewel head and red beaded eyes and metal wire wrapped body. I think of this as a statement piece. It would look nice on...

    View full details
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00