Skip to content
New sellers added regularly!
New sellers added regularly!

Under $25

Looking for meaningful gifts that don’t break the bank? Explore unique and affordable finds from Finger Lakes sellers, all $25 and under. From handmade treats and self-care essentials to charming accessories and thoughtful tokens, this collection proves that small gifts can still leave a big impression.

  • Maple Cotton Candy Mix.png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Maple Cotton Candy Mix 1 Pound

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Maple Cream 16 Oz Glass Transparent .png
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $16.00
    Current price $10.00

    Glass Maple Cream (Choose size)

    Taft's Flat Rock Maple Syrup

    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $16.00
    Current price $10.00
  • *Clearance* Strawberry Dangle Earrings in Copper - handmade earrings by Gorges Wire Design | Shop Finger Lakes NY
    Sold out
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00

    *Clearance* Strawberry Dangle Earrings in Copper

    Gorges Wire Design

    Care Instructions for All JewelryJewelry will tarnish over time, unfortunately any metal (enameled or treated for tarnish prevention) will oxidize ...

    View full details
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $21.00
    Original price
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $21.00
    Current price $21.00
    Sold out
  • Bacon Cheddar Biscuits handmade organic dog treats with Duvall Farms Bacon from The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen.
    Assorted handmade organic dog treats in a 9x9 grid, listed as follows: Bacon Cheddar Biscuits, Beef + Blueberry Bites, Blueberry + Oat Bones, Chicken Feet, Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Bones, Peanut Butter Bones, Salmon Paws and Veal Liver Jerky, all from The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen in Canandaigua, NY.
    Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
    Original price
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99

    Build Your Own Bundle 🐾 Handmade Organic Dog Treats

    The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen

    Build Your Own Bundle – Mix & Match Any 2 Bags for $19.99 🐾 Our Build Your Own Bundle is designed for the intentional dog owner who values vari...

    View full details
    Original price $19.99 - Original price $19.99
    Original price
    $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99
  • Blueberry + Oat Bones, handmade organic dog treats from The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen with blueberries, oats, and honey on a white background with oat and blueberries nearby.
    Blueberry + Oat Bones, handmade organic dog treats from The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen with blueberries, oats, and honey on a marble surface
    Sold out
    Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
    Original price
    $12.99
    $12.99 - $12.99
    Current price $12.99

    Blueberry + Oat Bones 🫐 Gluten-Free Handmade Organic Dog Treats

    The Chosen Spot K9 Kitchen

    Blueberry + Oat Bones 🫐Gluten-Free Handmade Organic Dog Treats *A Gentle, Fiber-Forward Daily Reward* Our Blueberry + Oat Bones are gluten-free, ...

    View full details
    Original price $12.99 - Original price $12.99
    Original price
    $12.99
    $12.99 - $12.99
    Current price $12.99
    Sold out
  • Wooden maps and coasters
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    Finger Lakes Table Top Coasters

    Victor Wood Forge

    Finger Lakes Table Top Coasters - Handcrafted Wood Drink Coasters One of the best parts of my job is that I love to create new designs. These Finge...

    View full details
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
  • Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00

    Bourbon Whiskey Coasters | Laser Engraved Wood | Distillery Gift Set

    Victor Wood Forge

    Premium Bourbon & Whiskey Coasters - Handcrafted Wood Bar Decor Elevate your home bar with these stunning laser-engraved bourbon and whiskey co...

    View full details
    Original price $7.00 - Original price $7.00
    Original price
    $7.00
    $7.00 - $7.00
    Current price $7.00
  • Original price $5.99 - Original price $5.99
    Original price
    $5.99
    $5.99 - $5.99
    Current price $5.99

    Fragrant Lavender Sachet: Natural Moth Repellent, Calming Aroma

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    Tucked with care and filled with fragrant dried lavender buds, this sachet brings the calming scent of the countryside to any drawer, closet, or be...

    View full details
    Original price $5.99 - Original price $5.99
    Original price
    $5.99
    $5.99 - $5.99
    Current price $5.99
  • Auburn Leathercrafters Town Collar Pink
    Auburn Leathercrafters Town Collar Royal Blue
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $48.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    Current price $22.00

    Town Collar - Pink and Blue

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Timeless design, Wonderful sturdy collar Classic bridle leather construction Available in sizes for even the tiniest pup   ...

    View full details
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $48.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    Current price $22.00
  • Red White and Blue Cotton Rope Knotted Toy
    Red White and Blue Cotton Rope Toy with Leather Ring
    Original price $13.50 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $13.50
    $13.50
    $13.50 - $24.00
    Current price $13.50

    Natural Cotton and Leather Tug Toy - Ring, Knotted Rope - Limited Edition Red, White & Blue

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Limited Edition 100% Made in USA Cotton Rope and Natural Vegetable Tanned Leather Great for Interactive Play Description: ...

    View full details
    Original price $13.50 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $13.50
    $13.50
    $13.50 - $24.00
    Current price $13.50
  • Brass custom engraved nameplate with Crimson Text font
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Brass Large - for Collar Lengths 24", 26", 30", 34"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Sparky's Choice Grooming Loop Extender with rings
    Sparky's Choice Grooming Loop Extender in Pink
    Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
    Original price $20.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00

    Sparky's Grooming Strap Extender

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Sparky’s Grooming Strap Extender takes your grooming restraint setup past its limits, providing the perfect fit for dogs of all ...

    View full details
    Original price $20.00 - Original price $20.00
    Original price $20.00
    $20.00
    $20.00 - $20.00
    Current price $20.00
  • brass charm engraved with the word Gizmo on black
    stainless steel charm with the word Frey engraved in black
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Charm

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Do you need to add information to your dog's existing collar or leash? Has your information changed since you originally purchased your dog's colla...

    View full details
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Stainless Steel Large - for Collar Lengths 24", 26", 30", 34"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Tuscan Collar in turquoise with custom engraved nameplate
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Solid stainless steel or solid brass Seven available fonts Up to three lines of text Dropshipping available Four sizes, to fit ...

    View full details
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Grooming Loop features: Scissor Snap (securely fastens to any grooming table), Slide Stopper (easy to adjust and stays in place), D-Ring (an optional connection point for extra stability), and Side-Release Buckle (a safety release usable one handed)
    waterproof grooming loop with side release buckle in blue
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    Current price $12.00

    Sparky's Grooming Loop

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: A secure, adjustable grooming loop with built-in quick release and a secondary attachment point for added control. Waterproof,...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    Current price $12.00
  • leather dog toy shoe
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $22.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $22.00
    Current price $22.00

    Natural Leather Dog Toy

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: A simple, durable leather dog toy made for fetch, tug, and hands-on play. Handmade from thick natural vegetable-tanned leather, ...

    View full details
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $22.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $22.00
    Current price $22.00
  • a tail we could wag leash with paw prints and hearts and in primary colors
    Sale Sale
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $44.00
    $24.00 - $26.40
    $24.00 - $26.40
    Current price $24.00

    a tail we could wag Leash - Puppy Love

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Handmade Guatemalan cotton weave Beautiful vibrant colors Nylon webbing lined Solid brass snap Hand or machine washable if need...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $44.00
    $24.00 - $26.40
    $24.00 - $26.40
    Current price $24.00
    Sale Sale
  • Sparky's Choice orange leash keeper with scissor snap and adjustalbe disk
    Original price $17.00 - Original price $17.00
    Original price $17.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00

    Sparky's Adventure Leash Keeper

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Waterproof, odor proof, easy to clean Genuine USA-made BioThane®-coated webbing Makes keeping your kennel, mudroom – or toolroo...

    View full details
    Original price $17.00 - Original price $17.00
    Original price $17.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00
  • Leather-Brite-4floz-Leather-Conditioner-Auburn-Leathercrafters
    Leather-Brite-4floz-Leather-Conditioner-Auburn-Leathercrafters
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00

    Leather Brite

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: • Repels water, grease, and oil • Long-lasting finish • Dries clear • Won’t discolor leather or vinyl Description: Leather B...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $12.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00
    $12.00 - $12.00
    Current price $12.00
  • country cow bell
    group photo of small, medium, and large country cow bells
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00 - $16.00
    $14.00 - $16.00
    Current price $14.00

    Country Cow Bell

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Slides securely on belt or collar Three sizes Attractive copper finish Listen here: Small Medium Large Description: 100% sou...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00 - $16.00
    $14.00 - $16.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Original price $3.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price $3.00
    $3.00
    $3.00 - $8.00
    Current price $3.00

    Replacement Screw for Sparky's Choice or Seneca Side Release Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Occasionally, we get a phone call from a customer asking for a replacement screw for our Sparky's Choice or Seneca Side Release Collar. Now you can...

    View full details
    Original price $3.00 - Original price $8.00
    Original price $3.00
    $3.00
    $3.00 - $8.00
    Current price $3.00
  • Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Stainless Steel Extra Small - for Collar Lengths 8", 10", 12"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Original price $24.00 - Original price $40.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $40.00
    $24.00 - $40.00
    Current price $24.00

    Lake Country Stitched Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Naturally vegetable tanned bridle leather reinforced with complementary stitching Raw edges, smoothed and beveled for comfort B...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $40.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $40.00
    $24.00 - $40.00
    Current price $24.00