Skip to content
New sellers added regularly!
New sellers added regularly!

Under $25

Looking for meaningful gifts that don’t break the bank? Explore unique and affordable finds from Finger Lakes sellers, all $25 and under. From handmade treats and self-care essentials to charming accessories and thoughtful tokens, this collection proves that small gifts can still leave a big impression.

  • Rudy wearing Puppy Love dog collar
    Sale Sale
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00
    $22.20 - $26.40
    $22.20 - $26.40
    Current price $22.20

    a tail we could way Side-Release Dog Collar - Puppy Love

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: PRICE REFLECTS 40% DISCOUNT OFF RETAIL PRICE. Handmade Guatemalan cotton weave Beautiful vibrant colors Durable quick release b...

    View full details
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00
    $22.20 - $26.40
    $22.20 - $26.40
    Current price $22.20
    Sale Sale
  • Brass custom engraved nameplate with Crimson Text font
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Brass Extra Small - for Collar Lengths 8", 10", 12"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Metro Paws Poopcase Translucent
    Metro Paws Poopcase in Seafoam
    Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
    Original price $16.99
    $16.99
    $16.99 - $16.99
    Current price $16.99

    Metro Paws Poopcase

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Made of plant-based compostable materials and has a soft silicone-like feel. Assembled in the USA by a sheltered workshop. Cara...

    View full details
    Original price $16.99 - Original price $16.99
    Original price $16.99
    $16.99
    $16.99 - $16.99
    Current price $16.99
  • Bell Door Hanger Bernese Red
    Bell Door Haner Bernese Brown
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    Bell Door Hanger - Bernese Mountain Dog

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Give your dog a clear way to ask to go outside with a dog door bell that’s both useful and decorative. Our USA-made Bernese Moun...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Bear Bell with Leather Strap
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00

    Bear Bell with Leather Strap

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Keep track of your best friend on walks while alerting wildlife to your presence Securely slides onto collar or belt Descri...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00
    $14.00 - $14.00
    Current price $14.00
  • Auburn Leathercrafters Town Collar Black
    group of leather town collars in burgundy, tan, black, and red
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $48.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    Current price $22.00

    Town Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Timeless design Wonderfully sturdy collar Classic bridle leather construction Available in sizes for even the tiniest pup D...

    View full details
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $48.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    $22.00 - $48.00
    Current price $22.00
  • key ring in Antigua pattern
    Original price $16.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price $16.00
    $16.00
    $16.00 - $16.00
    Current price $16.00

    a tail we could wag Key Ring

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Guatemalan cotton weave Natural veg-tanned leather Brass plated steel hardware Description: Not your ordinary key ring, a ...

    View full details
    Original price $16.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price $16.00
    $16.00
    $16.00 - $16.00
    Current price $16.00
  • Braided leather pull tab, correction tab, training tab, steady tab
    Braided leather pull tab, correction tab, training tab, steady tab
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $23.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $23.00
    Current price $22.00

    Braided Pull / Correction Tab

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Great training aid Make off-leash work easier with this short, lightweight training tab that won’t get tangled or trip up you o...

    View full details
    Original price $22.00 - Original price $23.00
    Original price $22.00
    $22.00
    $22.00 - $23.00
    Current price $22.00
  • Brass custom engraved nameplate with Crimson Text font
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Brass Medium - for Collar Lengths 18", 20", 22"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Brass custom engraved nameplate with Crimson Text font
    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Brass Small - for Collar Lengths 14", 16"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • a tail we could wag side release dog collar size guide
    a tail we could wag Mystic extra small fabric collar
    Sale Sale
    Original price $28.00
    Original price $28.00 - Original price $28.00
    Original price $28.00
    Current price $15.60
    $15.60 - $15.60
    Current price $15.60

    a tail we could wag Side-Release Extra Small Dog or Cat Collar - Mystic

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: for extra small dogs & for cats who don’t need a breakaway buckle lots of great patterns soft and flexible for comfort adju...

    View full details
    Original price $28.00
    Original price $28.00 - Original price $28.00
    Original price $28.00
    Current price $15.60
    $15.60 - $15.60
    Current price $15.60
    Sale Sale
  • Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Stainless Steel Small - for Collar Lengths 14", 16"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Saratoga Suede collar group
    Sale Sale
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $50.00
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $50.00
    Original price $32.00
    $16.00 - $25.00
    $16.00 - $25.00
    Current price $16.00

    Saratoga Suede Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: PRICES REFLECT 50% DISCOUNT OFF RETAIL PRICES Please measure carefully. ALL SALES ARE FINAL. Bright, beautiful colors Nubuck le...

    View full details
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $50.00
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $50.00
    Original price $32.00
    $16.00 - $25.00
    $16.00 - $25.00
    Current price $16.00
    Sale Sale
  • Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00

    Custom Engraved Nameplate - Stainless Steel Medium - for Collar Lengths 18", 20", 22"

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Original price $15.00 - Original price $15.00
    Original price $15.00
    $15.00
    $15.00 - $15.00
    Current price $15.00
  • Minnie Maddie Red Dog Collar for small dogs
    Minnie Maddie Dog Collars
    Sale Sale
    Original price $44.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $76.00
    Original price $44.00
    Current price $22.00
    $22.00 - $38.00
    Current price $22.00

    Minnie Maddie Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: PRICES REFLECT 50% DISCOUNT OFF RETAIL PRICES Please measure carefully. ALL SALES ARE FINAL. This item is being discontinued. P...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $76.00
    Original price $44.00
    Current price $22.00
    $22.00 - $38.00
    Current price $22.00
    Sale Sale
  • Sparky's Standard Buckle Collar Red
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $32.00
    $24.00 - $32.00
    Current price $24.00

    Sparky's Choice Standard Buckle Collar

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Dirty dogs, rejoice! Our Sparky’s Choice Collar is easy to-clean: soap and water does the trick. Odors wash away, too! Made fro...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $32.00
    $24.00 - $32.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Cat Bell Hanger Brown
    Cat Bell Hanger Black
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    Bell Door Hanger - Cat

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Add charm and function to your doorway with a hanging door bell that helps pets communicate potty-time needs. Our USA-made Cat B...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • belt key holder slide on style in burgundy bridle leather with nickel hardware
    Belt Key Ring - Black - Snap-On
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $18.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00 - $18.00
    $14.00 - $18.00
    Current price $14.00

    Belt Key Holder

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Natural veg-tanned leather Metal hardware Description: Auburn Leathercrafters' Belt Key Holder is a great addition to a tr...

    View full details
    Original price $14.00 - Original price $18.00
    Original price $14.00
    $14.00 - $18.00
    $14.00 - $18.00
    Current price $14.00
  • extra small a tail we could wag Traditional Earth pattern dog collar
    a tail we could wag Traditional Multi extra small fabric collar
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    a tail we could wag Side-Release Extra Small Dog or Cat Collar - Traditional

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: for extra small dogs & for cats who don’t need a breakaway buckle lots of great patterns soft and flexible for comfort adju...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Smith's Leather Balm container with brush and cloth and a dog collar in the background
    Smith's Leather Balm container
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price $10.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00

    Smith's Leather Balm

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Smith’s Leather Balm is a nontoxic leather conditioner designed to restore worn leather and protect new leather goods. No harsh ingredients means n...

    View full details
    Original price $10.00 - Original price $10.00
    Original price $10.00
    $10.00
    $10.00 - $10.00
    Current price $10.00
  • Original price $12.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    Current price $12.00

    Bear Bell with Snap

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: For those who need a little “advance warning” while on a hike. Convenient snap for easy on/off. Listen here for a sample of the ...

    View full details
    Original price $12.00 - Original price $14.00
    Original price $12.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    $12.00 - $14.00
    Current price $12.00
  • a tail we could wag traditional mystic pattern in primary colors
    a tail we could wag leash in Mystic pattern
    Sale Sale
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price $44.00
    $24.00 - $30.00
    $24.00 - $30.00
    Current price $24.00

    a tail we could wag Leash - Mystic

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Handmade Guatemalan cotton weave Beautiful vibrant colors Nylon webbing lined Solid brass snap Hand or machine washable if need...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price $44.00
    $24.00 - $30.00
    $24.00 - $30.00
    Current price $24.00
    Sale Sale
  • puppy playing with cotton rope tug toy ring
    Knotted cotton rope dog toy with leather reinforcement
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $28.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $28.00
    $24.00 - $28.00
    Current price $24.00

    Natural Cotton and Leather Tug Toy - Ring, Knotted Rope

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: A durable natural tug toy for dogs, available in ring and knotted rope styles. Handmade in the USA from vegetable-tanned leather...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $28.00
    Original price $24.00
    $24.00 - $28.00
    $24.00 - $28.00
    Current price $24.00
  • a tail we could wag side release dog collar size guide
    a tail we could wag dog collar Mystic
    Sale Sale
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00
    $22.20 - $26.40
    $22.20 - $26.40
    Current price $22.20

    a tail we could wag Side-Release Dog Collar - Mystic

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description:   Handmade Guatemalan cotton weave Beautiful vibrant colors Durable quick release buckle Nylon webbing lined Brass D-ring Hand ...

    View full details
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00 - Original price $47.00
    Original price $40.00
    $22.20 - $26.40
    $22.20 - $26.40
    Current price $22.20
    Sale Sale
  • Grooming Tether with notes on special features
    Sparky's Choice grooming teather
    Original price $12.25 - Original price $12.25
    Original price $12.25
    $12.25
    $12.25 - $12.25
    Current price $12.25

    Sparky's Grooming Safety Tether - Cam Buckle

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Not every dog stays positioned exactly where you’d like, and not every grooming table has an attachment point where you need one...

    View full details
    Original price $12.25 - Original price $12.25
    Original price $12.25
    $12.25
    $12.25 - $12.25
    Current price $12.25
  • Light Blue Sparky's Tether Keeper
    Sparky's Grooming Safety Tether in teal
    Original price $17.00 - Original price $17.00
    Original price $17.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00

    Sparky's Grooming Safety Tether

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Sparky’s Grooming Safety Tether creates an extra attachment point wherever you need it. Waterproof, odor-resistant, colorfast,...

    View full details
    Original price $17.00 - Original price $17.00
    Original price $17.00
    $17.00
    $17.00 - $17.00
    Current price $17.00
  • cowbell with antique brass finish and tan bridle leather strap. next to ruler showing 5" tall.
    cowbell with antique brass finish and tan bridle leather strap
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $25.00
    Original price $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $25.00
    Current price $21.00

    Upland & Downstream Prairie Cow Bell

    Auburn Leathercrafters

    Short description: Slides securely on belt or collar Three sizes Attractive copper finish Listen here: Small Medium Large Description: The Upla...

    View full details
    Original price $21.00 - Original price $25.00
    Original price $21.00
    $21.00
    $21.00 - $25.00
    Current price $21.00
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    StorySprout and the Missing Candy Canes

    Keuka Roots

    StorySprout and the Missing Candy CanesA StorySprout™ Christmas Adventure Something sweet has gone missing—and Christmas needs a little StorySprout...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    ED_Handcrafted-Art-Journal_Finery-Wood-Cover_Watercolor-Paper

    Eltimar Design

    The cover to this journal is a Zentangle Art Piece that Mary drew years ago. Last week, she was looking at it, and thought, "Wouldn't this make a ...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00

    ED_Handcrafted-Art-Journal_Floral-Wood-Cover_Mixed-Media-Paper

    Eltimar Design

    The cover to this journal used to be the lid on a jewelry box. Now it's been Eltimar'd. Mary cleaned it, painted the flowers' centers, filled it ...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
    Sold out
  • Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99

    Christmas at the Lake Cocktail Infuser | Holiday Mocktail Kit | Christmas Drink Gift | Mason Jar Infusion Kit | Finger Lakes Gift

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    🎄 Christmas at the Lake – Cocktail & Mocktail Infuser 🎄 A Little Taste of Christmas in the Finger Lakes! Bring the warmth and magic of a Fing...

    View full details
    Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99
  • Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
    Original price
    $13.99
    $13.99 - $13.99
    Current price $13.99

    Feta’s Lake Journey - keepsake hard copy

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    🐾 A Lake Adventure With a Little Dog—and a Big Heart Meet Feta, a rescue dog discovering life at the lake in Feta’s Lake Journey, a heartwarming c...

    View full details
    Original price $13.99 - Original price $13.99
    Original price
    $13.99
    $13.99 - $13.99
    Current price $13.99
  • Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99

    Keuka Sunset Sangria Infusion Kit | DIY Sangria Gift | Wine Lover Gift | Finger Lakes Gift | Hostess Gift | Mason Jar Cocktail Kit

    Finger Lakes Baskets

    🍷 Keuka Sunset Sangria Infusion Kit A Taste of the Finger Lakes in Every Sip! Bring the beauty of a Keuka Lake sunset to your next gathering with ...

    View full details
    Original price $14.99 - Original price $14.99
    Original price
    $14.99
    $14.99 - $14.99
    Current price $14.99
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00

    StorySprout Goes to School

    Keuka Roots

    StorySprout Goes to SchoolThe Little Solo That Found Its CourageA sprinkle of cinnamon magic, a pair of crooked reindeer antlers, and one little v...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $5.00
    $5.00 - $5.00
    Current price $5.00
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $3.00
    $3.00 - $3.00
    Current price $3.00

    StorySprout™ and the Blizzard That Lost Its Roar

    Keuka Roots

    StorySprout™ and the Blizzard That Lost Its RoarA Snowy Tale of Blustery Winds, Unexpected Friendships & the Magic of Lending a HandEighteen in...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $3.00
    $3.00 - $3.00
    Current price $3.00
    Sold out
  • Sold out
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $2.00
    $2.00 - $2.00
    Current price $2.00

    StorySprout™ Christmas Coloring Adventures

    Keuka Roots

    🌱 StorySprout™ Christmas Coloring Adventures15 Magical Coloring Pages Filled with Creativity, Kindness & Christmas Magic! 🎄Grab your crayons, c...

    View full details
    Original price $0.00 - Original price $0.00
    Original price $0.00
    $2.00
    $2.00 - $2.00
    Current price $2.00
    Sold out